|
| ||
Naso
It is axiomatic that the Torah contains no superfluous words,
and that every letter holds the infinite wisdom of HaShem -
all of which makes the long, repetitive account of the
offerings of the Nesi'im (the tribal princes) that much more
difficult to understand. For twelve consecutive days, the
princes brought their dedication offerings to the Mishkan, and
each day's identical offerings are exhaustively and precisely
detailed. Why ? Why couldn't the Torah simply say that
such-and-such were the offerings of the Nesi'im every day, and
then mention each of the Nesi'im by name? Elsewhere the Torah
uses such a phrase - "dvar yom b'yomo" - "each on its own
day"? Why was it necessary to state that each day, each Nasi
brought this and this and this...all identical? And how indeed was it possible that each Nasi brought the
identical korban? And if the Torah itself says: "Vayakrivu es
korbanam" - "they brought their offerings" (Bamidbar 4:10),
why were they actually offered on consecutive days ? Why not
do it all at once? And how can HaShem be praised if the exact
offering is brought day after day? Don Yitzchak Abarbanel suggests an answer that is
interesting in its own right and because it seemingly
conflicts with a Midrash that he himself quotes. Don Abarbanel
writes that the Nesi�im gathered in advance and agreed to
bring identical offerings. As they were inducted as the tribal
heads, each one wanted to ensure that there would be no
religious one-upsmanship, competition, jealousy or strife
among them. They did not wish to compete with each other as to
who would bring what korban, in what quantity, at what
expense, and in what order. Each wanted to invoke HaShem's
blessings on his tribe. So they resolved to bring the same
offering, and all at the same time. "And the princes brought
their offerings before the altar" (ibid). At this point, HaShem intervened: "One Nasi per day, one
Nasi per day will bring their offerings" (ibid 11), not all at
once. If all the korbanos were brought together, people would
not know that each Nasi was bringing an individual korban.
They would merely think it was a general communal offering.
Nor would the onlookers know that everyone was bringing the
same offering, in the excitement and commotion of all the
offerings. HaShem decreed that each Nasi would receive the
appropriate honor, and that the identical korbanos would be
offered in the order of the masa'os, as the tribes marched in
formation. And so each day's korban was punctuated by "Zeh" -
this - no tribe's offering was greater than that of another. Yet, Don Abrabanel also quotes the Midrash that each Nasi
brought his korban on his own initiative, and each had its own
symbolism and meaning. Each Nasi was making a statement about
his tribe by focusing on the essential tribal designation that
emerged through the blessings of Yaakov, or on some defining
moment in the tribe's existence. Yehuda brought his korbanos
to symbolize his royalty, Yissachar to express his profound
connection to Torah, Zevulun corresponding to his partnership
in Torah with Yissachar, Reuven in commemoration of his
dramatic but incomplete rescue of Yosef, and on and on. Chazal expounded each entity and its unique symbolism for
that tribe - the silver plate, the silver basin, the golden
pan, every korban, etc. Each Nasi then brought the same thing,
on his own, but with a different kavana - a different mindset,
with a different set of experiences, perspective and
motivation. But how can both ideas be correct? Either all the Nesi'im
acted in concert and intentionally brought the same offering,
or each one acted on his own initiative - leaving the
potential for religious competition unabated? The answer is that, indeed, both ideas are correct -
because two people can do what appear to be identical acts,
and yet those acts are not at all alike or even similar. Isn't
that the reality of Jewish life ? Of halacha ? We all do what
appears to be, on the surface, the same things: we daven the
same words, we make the same brachos, we learn the same Daf in
Daf Yomi, we men wear identical pairs of tefillin. And yet, in
Tefila, one person's soul can be communing with HaShem,
another person's mind can contemplate the abstruse ideas of
prayer, another's spirits can be lifted by the experience, and
still another is eager to finish mouthing the words so he can
return to the conversation he is having with his neighbor. It all sounds the same and looks the same - but in fact it
is completely different, worlds apart, night and day in its
essence. The effort, sincerity, commitment and substance that
we put into each mitzva is what makes the crucial difference
in our lives - what makes the Torah for some the elixir of
life and for others (G-d forbid) a lifeless, spiritless,
insipid shell. The Nesi'im to their credit did agree on the details of
their individual offerings. But each offering is repeated in
totality to remind us that no two avodos are the same, and no
two people are identical, and no one's relationship with
HaShem is akin to another's. Each korban in its every
particular was wholly unlike any other in what most counted -
the intention of the giver - and so this idea had to be
recorded by the Torah for posterity. One would think that every Bar Mitzva is also the same -
usually, the boy puts on tefillin, reads the Torah and haftara,
offers a Dvar Torah, receives presents, etc. But one who
thinks that each one is identical because the external form
appears the same is gravely mistaken. Each person is unique,
and will in his life accentuate a different aspect of Torah
and Avoda - just like each tribe did. Each child will grow to
make a unique contribution to Jewish life that only he or she
can. Every person's Divine service is distinctive and
inimitable. Each day - each moment in time - has its Nasi, and
the measure of our success is seizing that moment for the
glory of our Creator, His Torah, and for the benefit of Klal
Yisrael. Rabbi Pruzansky is the spiritual leader of Congregation
Bnai Yeshurun of Teaneck, New Jersey, an Associate member of
the Young Israel Council of Rabbis.This Dvar Torah was written
in honor of Ari Pruzansky, whose Bar Mitzva is being
celebrated today. To receive a free e-mail subscription to NCYI�s weekly Torah Bulletin, send an email to: YI_Torah@lb.bcentral.com | ||







