Parshat Bamidbar
25 Iyar 5761
May 26, 2001
Daf Yomi: Kiddushin 19
Guest Rabbi:
Rabbi Avraham M.I. Avnit
Young Israel of Dayton, OH
Fire, Water and Desert
The Book of Numbers (Bamidbar) is the fourth of the five books of Moshe.
It relates the wanderings of the Israelites in the desert. Its
commandments, contrary to the cultic and sacrificial commandments in
Leviticus, deal to a large extent with the relations between man and his
fellow. The Torah's "bill of rights," which count all people together,
signifying their equality, therefore belongs in this volume. Deuteronomy
(Dvarim), the fifth and last book of the Torah, is essentially Moshe's
repetition of all the foregoing. As such, its message is that if indeed we
listen to the Torah and heed its commandments, both spiritual and
physical, every person will feel his value enhanced. If someone knows
that he is important, his morale will be boosted, and he will give his
best, to the benefit of society and himself.
The Bamidbar Chumash relates mostly to the history of the Israelites
during their wanderings in the wilderness from the second year to the
fortieth year. Our Chazal - sages - called it "Chumash-HaPkudim" - the
census Chumash, becuase of the census at the beginning and toward the end
(chapter 26) of the Chumash.
* * * *
Parshat Bamidbar is always read on the Shabbat before the festival of
Shavuot. There are manifold references by Chazal as to why this is so.
According to one of the amendments that Ezra HaSofer fixed, "tichleh shana
v'kileloteha," it is best to end the year with curses and to start the new
year with blessings. We read Parshat Bamidbar before the festival of
Shavuot in order to separate between the reproofs in Parshat Bechukotai
and Shavuot, which Chazal in Mishnayot Rosh HaShana 1:2 call the new year
for the fruit of trees.
The Baal HaTurim, Rabbi Yaakov the son of Asher, introduces a remarkable
way of remembering when the reading of Bamidbar occurs, "pikdu u'fischu,
menu v'itzru." "Pikdu" means a command referring to Parshat Tzav.
"U'fischu" refers to Pesach. Parshat Tzav, therefore, is read before
Pesach. "Menu" (counting) refers to Parshat Bamidbar. "V?itzru," which
means stopping or ending, refers to Shavuot. Shavuot is the last holiday
following Sfirat HaOmer which starts at the time of Pesach. Parshat
Bamidbar is read before the festival of Shavuot (also see: Shulchan Aruch
Orach Chaim (428:4) where it is written, "one always reads Sidrat Bamidbar
before Atzeret (Shavuot)."
Rabbi Meir Shapira, the head of the Yeshivat Chachmei Lublin, commented on
the above comparisons. At the time of Pesach, the Israelites were redeemed
on their own virtues. On the other hand, at the time of Shavuot, "Zman
Matan Torateinu," each Jew had to come with his family record in order to
take part in the "Kabbalat HaTorah," receiving the Torah.
Rabbi Chaim Yosef David Azulai (HaChida) tries to resolve the following
question: "Why does the Torah mention, at the very beginning of the Sidra,
that HaShem spoke to Moshe, "Bemidbar Sinai," in the wilderness of Sinai?
Do we not know that it occurred in the wilderness? The Chida then says
that the numerical values (gematriya) of the Hebrew letters of the two
words "Bemidbar Sinai" are equivalent to the word "B?shalom," in peace
(378). He then quotes Chazal in the Midrash Mechilta of Parshat Yitro; the
Israelites came to Sinai as one people with one heart, as it says,
"Vayichan sham Yisrael" - Israel encamped there (In singular form). Only
when they were united, making peace between a man and his fellow (as
before the high holy days), were they worthy to receive the Torah.
The Midrash Raba points out that if a person behaves as one who gave
everything away for the sake of the Torah, he will be able to acquire
Torah and wisdom. The Chassidic Rebbe Menachem Mendel of Kotzk remarks
upon that Midrash by saying that a man is supposed to be happy in his
portion. He is not to be dependent on his fellowman. On the contrary, he
should be independent in the "wilderness" of life. He is a "midbar"
striving in Torah and rising to the highest level of kedusha (holiness).
Furthermore, Chazal in the Midrash Raba (1:7) say, "The Torah was given
with three things: with fire, with water and in the wilderness.
By Fire: Every Jew can reach and have the flame and enthusiasm for his
Father in heaven. HaShem appeared to Moshe in fire at the burning bush.
The Torah was given to us on Mount Sinai, in fire. The light of the Torah
will eventually drive away the darkness of wickedness. Even one light can
achieve a great deal. Hence, a religious person may never give up hope.
Because, in the final analysis, truth will triumph over falsehood. Fire
may bring goodness and blessing. It brings light and warmth. But, if one
is not careful with fire, it may bring destruction. It is the same with
Torah. If we fulfill the commandments with love and conviction then we
shall reap happiness and contentment, but if we deviate from the right
path and neglect the Torah it may bring about exile and destruction.
Our Chazal found an incredible comparison between the husband-wife
relationship and our relationship with HaShem. In the Hebrew words for man
and woman, "ish" and" isha," there is the word "esh," which means fire.
They also each contain one of the two letters of HaShem's name. Chazal
teach us that in a good relationship, the Shchina (Divine Presence) rests
between them. But, if G-d forbid, the relationship is bad, the Shchina
will depart and only fire will be left.
By Water: This is the lowliness and the degradation of the spirit, the
presence of mind, the calmness and the clearness of the mind. Our sages
pointed out that the Torah contains the special quality of water, whereby
it flows down from the mountains and collects in the valleys. So it is
with the Torah: it leaves the egotistical person and lands among the
humble people. We may also add that there are no barriers for water. It
can become a mighty force that breaks down obstacles. So it is with
HaShem's promise of the remembrance of Torah among Israel. Our faith
breaks through family and environmental obstacles. Even when a child grows
up in complete ignorance of Torah, he may become religious and force the
parents to reevaluate their attitudes toward Judaism. Presumably this is
what the prophet Isaiah (11:9) referred to when he said: "For the earth
shall be full of the knowledge of HaShem, as the waters cover the sea."
It is the eternity of our Torah that will prevail forever.
There is also another interesting aspect concerning water. Mighty rivers
and stormy seas are only numberless small drops of water. They are united
beyond recognition - millions of them are gathered into one place,
eventually to become great waters which may break through and flood
everything in their way. The same principle applies to our religion. The
future of our faith lies in complete unity. As individuals, we are
powerless to stand up against the streams of agnostic ideology. But if we
stand united in faith and courage, we can become a power which will resist
the attacks directed against our beliefs.
By the Desert: The desert is a symbol of our decency, modesty and
abstemiousness. As our Chazal say in Pirkei Avot 1:4, "This is the way
of Torah: eat bread with salt, drink water in small measure, sleep on the
ground, live a life of deprivation - but toil in the Torah! If you do
this you are praiseworthy and all is well with you." The Torah is
ownerless like the desert. There is no monopoly over it. It does not
belong to any particular tribe or family. It is not confined only to the
righteous and the prophets.
* * * *
According to Nachmanides (Ramban), the whole Book of Bamidbar is concerned
with temporary precepts. The commandments are for the Jewish people in the
wilderness and are meant to convey the wondrous miracles performed on
their behalf.
The Tabernacle, which moved in the midst of the camp was a type of Mount
Sinai on which the Torah was given, accompanying them on all their
journeys. In other words, the Tabernacle was a mobile Sinai in the midst
of them: the heavens and the heaven of heavens transplanted and brought
down to earth. Moreover, Rabbi Yehuda HaLevi explains in his Kuzari
(2:26): "The camp and its divisions are to be compared to the body and its
constituent limbs--the Tabernacle being to the camp what the heart is to
the body."
Rabbi Meir Shapira of Lublin said that HaShem created the Torah for
eternity, to be fulfilled at any time, in all conditions. Throughout
history, our people have devoted themselves to keeping its
commandments--in fire, water and desert. We can see this in the singular
self-sacrifice by Avraham Avinu in fire, the sacrifice of Nachshon ben
Aminadav in water, and the mesirut nefesh of Klal Yisrael in the desert.