(2 Essays from my
forthcoming volume on Shemot)
The Exile in Egypt:
Rav Aharon Levine is among the many writers who theorized about the
ultimate goal of our exile in Egypt. A common idea in many seforim
is that we would learn about the abominations we must avoid as G-d�s
chosen people. However, Rav Levine finds a different ethical
message. After out prolonged period of suffering and persecution, we
would learn human decency for all G-d�s creatures, doing to others
what we have longed for our ourselves, for, as he explains, one who
has never hungered cannot understand fully a cry for bread. The
Haftarah for this Sidra begins (Yeshayahu, 27:6) as follows: �In
years� (understood) to come, �Jacob will strike roots, Israel will
sprout and flower.� The opening verb, however, rings of the first
verb in our Chumash: �.... the children of Israel who are coming to
Egypt� � a strange verb usage itself). Rav Levine�s ingenious and
interpretive idea is: the arrival of the Israelites to Egypt - had a
Divine purpose � that Jacob should strike deep roots for Israel to
flower beautifully as a moral nation.
Rav Aharon Levine
..............................
The following alternative interpretation of the question might be
called a 20th Century response:
Many volumes state that the Egyptian exile-and-redemption is a model
and precursor of the final redemption in the end of times. That is
why only these two (past and future) events are referred to by the
special term �Geulah� G-d wished at this early stage in Jewish
history to show us a model to carry us through a long and bitter
exile of centuries with hope and faith. Our exile in Egypt would
demonstrate that no matter how seemingly impossible our situation,
G-d is the master and ultimate power. Every step of the way He
controlled � exile, persecution, gradual steps leading to
redemption, and the final exodus. So, too, will the final ultimate
one proceed.
Just as before that exodus, we gained favor in the eyes of Egyptians
who gave us silver and gold vessels to make up for the years of
slavery, the modern day �Egyptians� (world powers who had persecuted
us for centuries) tried to make up for their cruelty, and for
looking the other way as six million Jews were slaughtered, by
voting in the United Nations for a Jewish State, to soothe their
consciences.
But just at the Egyptians had a change of heart and pursued us to
the Sea of Reeds with intentions of annihilation (as spelled out in
the great Shirah sung by our people), the world has also had a
change of heart, and Israel finds itself pictured in the
international press, and by so many political spokesmen, as the
mighty Goliath persecuting the poor Davids. Just as the Egyptian
confrontation ended with Israel triumphant, declaring: �G-d shall
rule for ever and ever,� the day will soon come that this will be
repeated in our times, and G-d and His people will have the
unltimate victory.
Rabbi Meir Dovid Kahane
Problems of Galut Life � Ancient and Modern:
(Shemot 1:7) And the children of Israel were fruitful, and increased
greatly, and multiplied, and waxed very mightily � and the land was
full of them.
The combination-phrase of �fruitful and multiply� is so common that
it is found (in various grammatical forms) no less than nine times
in Chumash Berashit alone. The fact that in this verse it is broken
apart by an inserted verb (�increased greatly,� based on a root
which means insect) demands attention. Among commentators who
discuss this fact was R� Azaryah Figo in his masterpiece "Binah
L'itim". He feels that this is meant to show that this increase was
not for the fulfillment of the Mitzvah, but represents the carnal
pursuit of animal lust, hence the root "insect". (This point is
already noted and emphasized by the Sfomo.) So too the phrase
immediately afterward ( "waxed very mightily"] deals with financial
success, and the doubling of "very" indicates that they became very
substantial people. This leads to the final phrase already analyzed
by our Chazal, that they began to spread about the country (the
suburbs), visiting the theatres and other such pursuits, all of
which help explain the jealousy of the local Egyptian community,
leading to servitude.
In the up-to-now very rare volume "Givat Shaul" by Rav Shaul HaLevi
Mortira, the head of the Sephardic Jewish community of Amsterdam in
the 17th century (Gevuos Shaul - reprinted in 1991, Brooklyn, NY],
the author goes through great lengths in castigating Jewish
communities in Golus for their excessive indulgence in luxuries,
large homes, and expensive clothing, all of which directly create
jealousy and hatred and are a major cause of our history of exile
from land to land. Had we not behaved thus in Egypt, our servitude
there would have been light and bearable, since our major purpose in
Egypt was to observe the abominable life and moral decadence of this
"advanced" civilization before we received the Torah, so as to leam
how not to behave. The severe extent of our suffering was caused by
our new Golus life-style. [His essay picturing life in Amsterdam in
his days is so relevant to our time, and so powerful, that it truly
deserves a complete translation / for modern Jews to reflect upon.]
He notes that after the start of some tax-type servitude, verse 12
records: "And as they afflicted them, so they multiplied and so they
spread" - what does this verse tell us? Instead of learning from the
error of their luxurious life-style and seeking to remove the cause
of the jealousy, they continued their ways and "spread out"- looking
for other neighborhoods and suburbs that might treat them better.
Thus indeed [conclusion of that verse) the Egyptians became
disgusted with the Jewish people. The next verse indicates an
increase in their servitude to "back-breaking" labor.
He concludes his essay with a sad lament that this is an old Jewish
problem, which cannot be solved by individuals but must gain the
attention and united action of the entire Jewish community, but he
knows alas that this is "very difficult". [to this very day!]
Rav Shaul HaLevi Mortira